In January 2012, the 11 Second Club set the challenge of animating to a Hindi audio. We saw many great entrants rise to the challenge, with Peter Nagy taking the crown of first place. In doing so, he becomes the first person to win with both traditional and 3D entries!
Now this interview is a little different. I was made aware AnimSchool wished to steal a march on our interview and talk to Peter about his workflow and using the Malcon rig. It is a wonderful interview, which you may find here.
It did however put the pressure on to go a little deeper.
You created and run the traditional animation resource, the Living Lines Library. The artwork shown looks considered rather than randomly posted. Please talk a bit about your reason for building the site and your personal values for the choice in work the site presents.
In its beginnings, I had a couple of thoughts in mind. Why isn’t there any website that can bring together material from animation films? And why there cannot be a site where the pencil tests are systematized, posted alongside other production artwork?
It all started back in 2010, after producing Animated Heaven. I had an allergy and the illness was quite serious, meaning I had to go to hospital for a couple of weeks. When I could leave, during the recovery I quickly reserved the livlily.blogspot address for myself. I thought I’d rather start the website now, because maybe later I might not have an opportunity.
This was when the uploading started until the publication, from October till December, from my secret collection. I had been collecting animation material for a while from the internet and from the films I worked in during my career. I didn’t want to keep them in a drawer or on a private site. Now when I search for artwork material on the net, sometimes I only find 1 or 2 pictures of a film but if the searching is more effective, and a more substantial material collected on my winchester in one of the folders of a film, I compile an article on it. Or if the material is more complete, I put it on the main page.
I love searching for and it’s a pleasure to me when I find concept material in the huge net-ocean. If something is strikes my curiousity, I take a closer look, sniff around wink my eyes a few times and if they pass this instinctive authenticity test I collect them immediately together with their source. It was in this manner that I started to build, so there wasn’t so much awareness in the appearance of the artwork material (although in the first year, I only knew one thing for sure that the main article at the end of the year will be The Secret of Kells).
At first I thought there will only be black and white line drawings on the site, what is more, I believed that the pencil tests will be the main profile of Livlily. However, the page began to shape itself and after a while it became clearer. In the meantime, I realized that storyboards are drawn for every film, this is how the first works from 3D productions appeared.
In the beginning, there weren’t enough colour on the site. Later on, some painted backgrounds and colour background concepts appeared beside the background layouts, and finally, all kinds of pictures which were hand drawn or digitally painted. With this, the category of artwork materials strengthened and besides the ancient, traditional technique we could get an insight to the workflow of other animation genres on the site.
I try to stay neutral and don’t burden the articles with my own opinions. In this manner, the visitor can have a browse around quietly and undisturbed. I believe the most important article is always what I’m dealing with at the moment and I don’t necessarily choose from my favourite ones (although it is true that I tend to polish longer an entry on a favourite one.)
Besides the big features, I also upload pictures from lesser known or less successful films. To me, the most beautiful are the concept and production materials that they are completely ‘clean’. I mean that these characters, locations and separate little universes just dropped out of the egg shell and I only see the creators’ drive and talent on them. Here all of them are equal with their originality, clarity, independent from the fact whether their story will work in the finished film or not.
If you had to choose three personal favourites from Living Lines Library, which would you pick and why?
Lady and the Tramp (1955). This image is a bit contradictive. Despite that it is not too bright and clean I still see it as beautiful. It could mean a dirty street for you, or you notice the little gate in the middle which might lead you into the light. Probably everybody sees it according their own temperament. If I wanted to tell my own story, I would choose similar environment and atmosphere.
Time management is an important value for successful animation production. Especially with the danger of burning out your creativity. Please talk a bit about balancing Living Lines Library, your competition entries and also production through your employment.
Advertising, in which I presently work, can be a little bit unpredictable and January was a bit too busy at my workplace. There was a deadline of an important project at the end of the month which all made my taking part in the competition a bit uncertain. I knew if I wished to enter, I could only deal with it after work and at weekends. It soon became very important for me that January consists of 31 days. I needed all the time available, which is always short before the submission.
In these cases I use a simple magic trick to lengthen the days and hours: I sleep less! It is already hard for me to stop working once I have started. I wouldn’t have got much sleep anyway, because it is always on my mind. Whether the drive lasts for a month or even longer depends on the idea. There wasn’t any problem with my performance at my workplace, the project promised until the end of the month shifted to February and I took a day off on the 31st.
Living in Hungary means there is a difference in timezones, of which I am thankful for. On the last day, I was constantly looking at my watch nervously. The time goes by and the dreaded midnight comes... but, I can still work 6 more hours because of the time shift.
These extra hours are very important at the end. They were used to bend the straight smoke stripe of the flying cigarette to make the arc nicer.
In the meantime, the Living Lines Library rested a bit, but it was nice that it’s visitors kept it alive :)
Mother Earth is your seventh entry in the 11 Second Club, your second as winner. Throughout each entry, I have grown to admire your consistent wish to challenge and experiment with different styles and ideas. Please talk a bit about your motives for entering.
I won at the CGTalk mini animation challenge
two months before I arrived at The 11 Second Club. There weren’t many of us at the competition, yet this result encouraged me to try myself out in a more serious field. At that time, I had only been using 3D for my works for about a year. (I used digital 2D, Anime Studio before that, and even before, I used only my right hand for animation.)
I arrived at the territory during the shining of the flawless scaled, ultra-talented BJ Crawford, which wasn’t a safe period for a beginner. After the first two 3D works I had to realize that if I want to be timely it would be worth returning to the traditional technique. Thank God this change proved to be successful, with the promotional animation of the Power TV.
It was exactly a year before my winning work that I started animating on 11 seconds’ clips, back in 2008 October. For the audio Somebody's Gonna Win, I would have liked to have done a 2D and a 3D character looking at each other, face to face - this mixing of techniques matched the voice, and I hoped the audience would have appreciated it. However, at that time I was a beginner in 3D and I could only do a lipsync test). I finally produced this idea after the competition following Power TV (although in the meantime a mixed animation
had already been made by Bruno Carias Fogaça). This entry was a nice transition to my next work by which I returned to the beginnings, the 3D, somewhat more experienced.
From here onward, a story were beginning to take shape. From that time this was my main motivation. It is a little bit ironic, that now when the traditional technique has returned to the 11 Second Club with the winning works, it is me (editor of Livlily) who breaks this glory with a 3D work.
Upon announcing your intention to enter again, you acknowledged the following:
"After my latest outcome I had a little moan here at the forum, that I will never compete again :), but I have to admit, it was a bit too rash statement. "
It is a prime example that exploring unfamiliar territory can come at the risk of disappointment. At one time or another, from the beginner to the largest studios, we all have felt this disappointment. Many of us are just glad to see you back. Please talk a bit about your reaction to June's competition and your reasons for returning.
I know this is not going to be a tangible explanation, but after coming first in 2009, I had a feeling that I will win again here some day. I was chasing this dream and I really wanted to win. I always compete because I want to win. Not just taking part, trying myself out in the field, but win. This is the truth. It was like this, even at the first time when I started competing. However, the final results of 2011 June’s competition was my fifth disappointment!
On every occasion I do everything to make the current work of mine reflect my best knowledge at that moment. I did a little mental arithmetic and after the fifth position of Animated Heaven and the third position Chatty Cathy Pinocchio the glory I dreamed about had to come at this moment :D
I left the “only-locally” movements behind and forced myself to make full-body animation which I have to practice anyway. I worked with two characters in one scene and moved both of them. I didn’t want to cheat the scene with editing so that I don’t have to show them at the same time.
I think my idea was great. A lion, who is the king of animals, but he thinks more of himself and he thinks he’s even superior to his tamer (the man). He is just a spectacle in a circus, because he has a special talent: he can speak ("I have a voice!"). He is King, the talking Lion! So I did my best again and couldn’t even get into the first 11!
I believe the comments annoyed me, that some people couldn’t disregard the stiff lion’s mane and couldn’t pay attention to anything else. Yet upon reflection, I’m sorry if I was a disappointment to anybody with this behaviour. I have reassessed this animation since then according to the audience’s opinion. I believe it has some nice merits, however I can see its faults more clearly. My fury has passed, which I worked it into the play-boy character of Mother Earth :)
You also stated your intention to once again push your own boundaries. Please talk a bit about any goals you had when starting January's competition.
Han Liane-Cho is again in competition in December. He won the 11 Second Club competition a month before me back in 2009, also with 2D work. He hasn’t competed since, but I really thought he was going to win.
Only a few people have had the opportunity to try to win with both traditional and 3D animation. One of the most successful warriors to the cause was the Brazilian Bruno Celegão Monteiro. Bruno who won two times with 2D work and once he came third with 3D. The December result hasn’t came out when I started brainstorming on the January’s dialogue. My main drive was still: will there be anybody, an animator, who manage to win in 2D and in 3D as well? That would be a good story!
The audio was taken from the Bollywood film Deewar. Is Hindi-Urdu a foreign language to you? If so, did this influence your choice to animate the lip sync early in production?
My working method changed a bit at Chatty Cathy Pinocchio, I always start the animation with the lipsync since then. As a Hungarian animator, it is not always easy to find the right lip positions, let the dialogue be in English or in any other language. If I did the character’s animation first, I wouldn’t have any energy to work out the important details at the end of the month. So I do this part first. Therefore, I pass some evenings with the lipsync, and only then I start the animation of the body and I keep refining the lip positions so I deal most with it during the whole work.
The excitement is great at the beginning of the month and I don’t have the whole scene or character in my head. Still, I can start the work with the lipsync which I must begin because of the diminishing time. Once I manage to overcome this difficulty of finding the whole story, I will calm down. I do a little shadowboxing in the middle of the room and thus the work can be continued: the actual animation can begin!
During a conversation with Indian animator Dapoon Rai Dewan, he commented that your acting choices fitted admirably to Indian film culture. Please talk a bit about your planning stage for these characters and environment.
My approach to the voice was that it wasn’t a jabber (although I didn’t understand a word of it), but a text in Hindi language. I wanted to taking it literally. This might reflect that I’m stuck-in-the-mud but I didn’t want to ignore its origin and didn’t want to make an animation that “just came to my mind” for the voice.
This approach already implied the appearance. At the beginning, the environment only appeared vaguely, but I knew I wanted to see typical Indian characters with tanned skin, black hair and a big moustache.
I was already walking through Indian locations in my mind when I started searching on the net. I was looking for pictures of Indian people, streets, street musicians, beggars, turbans and sitars. I watched shots of how people played the guitar, the sitar, how they hold the instrument or how they sit while playing. As for the environment, I searched for an architectural motive. The one I found in silhouettes at first in the characteristic roof shapes. I wanted to solve the environment as simply as possible, yet I needed more than a silhouette, that’s how I got to my final reference.
(scene influences and models)
(turban influences and model)
You can see beggars and street musicians in the character reference images, yet I didn’t want to present my character in the second scene as any of them. (Although the ground is scattered by coins around him, he didn’t put out a bowl to collect them.) This is additional information, that depended on the render. I didn’t have time to work it out of course, but the story did work nicely even without it: in reality, (and somewhat inconceivably,) I wanted to represent him as a ‘holy man’ who got out of all earthly bounds.
Discussed in your previous interview with Eric Scheur, you mentioned the influence of Eric Goldberg for building beautiful arcs and shapes in your gestures. Kenny Roy highlighted this in your eCritique, particularly on frames 137-147. Can you talk a bit about adding these kinds of exaggerations into your 3D work?
These kind of sudden movements require these distortions and Malcolm made it possible for me. Although at the beginning, this change seemed a bit risky (Malcolm’s appearance didn’t seem transformable at first sight and I hadn’t worked with him before), it proved to be the best possible choice in the end. I could stretch him however I wanted and set him into any poses I pleased. This liberty was superb! I could put arcs in my character’s silhouette with such an ease which was only possible in drawing before.
At the closing gesture of my negative character – the part Kenny mentioned – I passed beyond the potentials of the rig and moved the vertex points of the fingers as well, so that the arcs would help the quick turning over of the hand.
Talk about how the eCritique enhanced or expanded on the ideas you had originally set out to animate.
I was very pleased to hear the praising words and changed the scenes before the HD render (although I was pleased to not have to make many wholesale changes).
I must add that unfortunately, English isn't my first language so I had some problems understanding. But I'm on it. I'm not going to give it up, I’m going to listen to it a few more times and I’ll get some help as well.
I believe it is always good to listen to feed back, especially if they refer to your weaknesses. Thanks again for the energetic analysis and good luck to Kenny for his short film, The Little Painter. I hope something special is about to be born. :)
Alright. I’ll try to be to the point.
1) August 2009: Blake ‘Charlie’ Black
Exciting start. Charlie’s story was yet fetched from my private life. Everything was based on the name, Charlie. The character. To my approach, this schizoid artist thinks he’s Charlie Chaplin. Conjuring up the table ballet is sweet at the end, but entirely, it is not intelligible. There could be a lot of correction on the animation, but it is OK, for the first time. I like the atmosphere of the dressing room. The dressing room, where the posters are not reflected (which also means I moved two characters in the end at the same time).
This is my longest work with the weakest result. I wanted to get in the ’short film’ category with it, but didn’t succeed. With the film noir style, not from too fresh medium, but again I scooped from personal, old favourites. The closing was a bit more common, but the appearance of the title is creative. The atmosphere is again dear to me, I like the ’Nagy Bar’ inscription on the glass, but I must admit, this is the poorest animation I have ever done with Norman. I’m surprised how I managed to finish all this in a month beside my work (but I remember my colleague, who was responsible for the lighting and render, that he was sleeping on his desk in working time after a busy working night :)
3) October 2009: Power TV Promo
Fresh and full of ideas! A new kind of phrasing on the site. The audience appreciated the literal approach of the text (all what is heard becomes alive). The animation is not indiscreet, moderate and nice (it disturbs me at the end that the head and the hand holding the Globe stop at the same time), however, the abundance of the ideas grows over this problem. This is its main merit: the ideas. Ever since, I have also had the highest ranking in the unique category - which is great!
4) August 2010: Animated Heaven
The situation is not clear again. At the voting, even the title did not give any clue to identify the location. I like the colours. The animation is ambiguous. The 2D old woman (who is supposed to be Bishop’s drawn version) not explicitly strong, a little bit repetitive, but it becomes a bit better at the second half. My 3D character is not worthy its 2D predecessor (the promoter of Power TV), he doesn’t move enough. The small gestures are missing from the hand when we see him beside the old woman. This is my most exhausting work. It came in fifth place thanks to the ideas and the mixing of the techniques.
5) March 2011: Chatty Cathy Pinocchio
6) June 2011: King the Talking Lion
Unfortunately, the contrast between the characters does not work. It is also over moved. There are a lot of movements and we do not know who to focus on. Looking at the characters separately, I like the animation otherwise (except the last scene, where we couldn’t find the right colours). At the beginning, I don’t feel the nervousness of the lion. There are nice details (the traner’s game with the crown or keeping the balance of the composition with the lion’s movements), however, despite we see a full-length animation and the idea is great, it did not bring the expected result. :D The mane should move more!
(The first circle has been closed by this, because I got the same evaluation in numbers and stars as in the case of my first entry.)
And finally, my most recent entry.
7) January 2012: Mother Earth
At last, the contrast works well. What I like in this work, is that it plays around the genres a little bit. It has a funnier, overplayed start which cools down and turns into drama at the end. And this change surprises us at the very end, at the grabbing of the soil. I like its seriousness it gives a kind of depth to the work, which is not necessarily youthful (if I consider the audience of the site), but mature. The body of my first character should move more beside its wide gestures, with various poses. Among others, I liked animating the gesticulation with the hands (frames 100-118), which was a spontaneous movement during shot of the reference scene. An interesting motive is the Earth which connects it with the Power TV.
During an interview for YouAnimator, discussing pre-production of your Chatty Cathy, you spoke of other artists who contributed towards your entry. Please discuss the value of having a network/team.
In my works, the role of the assisting colleagues are really important, without them, I’m only a one-winged albatross, that is why I mentioned this in that interview.
The hand-drawn Power TV Promo wouldn’t have been assembled if it wasn’t for Csaba Pépp’s help in the post work. For production of Mother Earth, circumstances were not the most favourable. My friends, whom I have been working together for a long time, were so overloaded with work in January that none of them could tell for sure whether they could help me if I entered. I modeled the church and the palm trees already at the beginning, but in making the more important accessories of the characters (turban, rug) I asked for an ex-colleague of mine, Patrice Creusot’s help. Thanks to Szabolcs Siklósi for the lighting and render settings, and to László Maczó for the post work (he helped me in the modification of Livlily’s blog sablon).
When the idea of the cigarette came (to fill in the silence after the first short sentence and to make the character more negative) I had to look for an effect simulator as well. I tried to avoid these extra and unnecessary supplements before, but this time I needed it. I wanted to make my story complete. The cigarette smoke was created by Attila Chovanecz.
I downloaded the sitar from a 3D model library. I changed its colours, I stretched strings on it, and then I had a very important character.
Many entrants ask if they can produce a clip as part of a team. Please talk a bit about some of the challenges of working as part of a team.
I believe if many people are working on a project, it is always worth thinking through the working process. If we start testing the lighting only after the completion of the animation, it might not be ready on time. Some time is always needed for render and post work, so the final animation must be finished a few days before the deadline.
In the case of the smoke, I had to clean up the movements of the first 40 frames as soon as possible (the character was in close contact with the cigarette at this part). This wasn’t easy, because I only see for sure whether the beginning works or not when I see the complete and final animation, so I keep refining the details until the end. We were planning to make a little sand FX at the end, when the street musician grasps a little soil. This was omitted since it would have been too problematic to simulate it and solved it with the falling of some pieces of ground.
My friend Szabolcs completed the lighting in the middle of the month. The first tests were made with a roughly moving character, but with the final environment. Later, we updated this scene - containing the light sources - with the continuously improved animation.
I had such an idea at the very end, (to avoid the attacks coming from the final render) that I would upload the whole scene in black-and-white or brown-and-white. I kept it a secret even before the lighting expert, he gets to know it just now, but I was simply unable to give up its colours and atmosphere in the end.
The excitement of the competition is great, that you have to clean up the concept quickly and precisely, you have to consider the possibilities and the workflow practically (and you have to carry it out consistently). I’m glad for the help from others. This help is invaluable and I can only give the credits in return. I’m pleased that they believe in the final result, too.
I love the organizing during work, which is just as exciting to me as making the animation itself. Together with that: when finally on 5th after a movie, I open the site terrified/excitedly to have a look at the results of the voting.
Congratulations again Pete and thank you for your time. I wish to leave you with Pete's development work for the clip. I you all enjoy!